The Ultimate Guide to Pearl Jewellery: Types, Grades & How to Buy

Pearls have a unique place in the world of gems. They are the only gemstone formed within a living creature. For centuries, they have symbolised purity, wisdom, and timeless elegance. Unlike diamonds or coloured stones that are cut and polished to reveal their beauty, a pearl's beauty is complete when it emerges from the mollusc.

Today, the pearl market can be complex. The terms "natural," "cultured," "freshwater," and "saltwater" are often used, but their meanings aren't always clear. Understanding these differences is the first step to making an informed and confident purchase. This guide removes the mystery. It provides the knowledge you need to appreciate the nuances of pearl quality and select the perfect piece of pearl jewellery, whether for yourself or as a gift.

Here is what you will learn:

The fundamental difference between natural and cultured pearls.
A detailed breakdown of the four main cultured pearl types: Akoya, Freshwater, Tahitian, and South Sea.
How to evaluate pearl quality using the value factors: lustre, surface, shape, colour, and size.
The real meaning behind pearl grading systems like AAA and A.
Practical steps for buying pearls, both online and in stores.
How to care for your pearls to ensure they last for generations.

Natural vs. Cultured Pearls: Demystifying the Terms

The most important distinction in the pearl world is between natural and cultured pearls.

Natural Pearls: These are extremely rare and formed entirely by chance. They occur when an irritant, like a grain of sand, accidentally works its way into a mollusc. The mollusc secretes layers of nacre (a crystalline substance) around the irritant to protect itself. Over several years, this process forms a pearl. Natural pearls are almost exclusively found in antique jewellery and command exceptionally high prices at auction. For all practical purposes, the modern pearl market consists of cultured pearls.
Cultured Pearls: These pearls are formed through a combination of human intervention and natural processes. A skilled technician surgically implants a small piece of mantle tissue (often with a shell bead nucleus) into a mollusc. The mollusc is then returned to the water, where it secretes nacre around the implant, just as it would with a natural irritant. The culturing process takes several years. The result is a real pearl. The term "cultured" simply denotes that the process was initiated by humans. Over 99% of pearls on the market today are cultured.

Key Takeaway: When you buy a new piece of pearl jewellery, you are buying cultured pearls. This is not a lower-quality product; it is the standard. The term "cultured" should be seen as a mark of a legitimate pearl, not a synthetic imitation.

The Four Main Types of Cultured Pearls

Cultured pearls are categorised by the type of mollusc that produces them and the water they are grown in. Each type has distinct characteristics.

1. Akoya Pearls

Origin: Saltwater. Primarily cultivated in Japan and China.
Mollusc: Pinctada fucata martensii, a small oyster.
Key Characteristics: Akoya pearls are known for their classic, round shape and exceptionally high lustre. They are the pearls most people picture when they think of a traditional strand. They typically range in size from 2mm to 10mm, with most falling between 6mm and 8mm.
Colours: Primarily white and cream, often with overtones of rose, silver, or ivory. They are also frequently bleached and then dyed to achieve a uniform colour or to create black Akoya pearls.
Best For: Someone seeking a classic, timeless look. The perfect first strand of pearls or elegant stud earrings.

2. Freshwater Pearls

Origin: Freshwater. Almost exclusively cultivated in China.
Mollusc: Hyriopsis cumingi, a mussel.
Key Characteristics: These are the most versatile and affordable pearls. A single mussel can produce 20-40 pearls at once. Traditionally, they were known for their irregular, rice-shaped forms, but modern farming techniques now produce round, near-round, and baroque shapes. Their lustre is typically softer and more satiny than that of Akoya pearls.
Colours: Naturally occur in white, cream, peach, pink, and purple. They are also easily dyed into a vast array of colours.
Best For: Excellent value for money. Ideal for fashion jewellery, casual wear, and those who want to experiment with colour and style without a major investment.

3. Tahitian Pearls

Origin: Saltwater. Cultivated in French Polynesia (with Tahiti as the main trading island).
Mollusc: Pinctada margaritifera, the black-lipped oyster.
Key Characteristics: Often called "black pearls," their colour range is far more complex. They naturally display a stunning spectrum of dark colours: peacock green, charcoal grey, silver, eggplant purple, and deep black. Their sizes typically range from 8mm to 16mm. They are known for their large size and exotic, dramatic appearance.
Colours: Never bleached; their colours are completely natural. The most prized colour is the "peacock" green, with a rainbow-like iridescence.
Best For: Making a bold, sophisticated statement. Perfect for someone with a modern, confident style.

4. South Sea Pearls

Origin: Saltwater. Cultivated in Northern Australia, Indonesia, and the Philippines.
Mollusc: Pinctada maxima, the large white-lipped or gold-lipped oyster.
Key Characteristics: The largest and most valuable of all cultured pearls. They range from 10mm to 20mm, with some even larger. Their nacre is exceptionally thick, giving them a unique, soft, satiny lustre that seems to glow from within. They have a long cultivation period (2-4 years), which contributes to their high value.
Colours: Naturally white, silver, and golden. Australian South Sea pearls are famed for their brilliant white colour, while Indonesian and Filipino pearls are known for rich, natural gold colours.
Best For: The ultimate luxury purchase. A South Sea pearl necklace or pair of earrings is a significant heirloom-quality investment.

The Five Value Factors: How to Judge Pearl Quality

elegance in pearls and metals

The price and desirability of any pearl are determined by five key factors. Understanding these will allow you to compare pearls effectively.

1. Lustre: The Most Important Factor

Lustre is the shine and brilliance reflected from the pearl's surface. High-quality lustre is sharp and bright; you should see a clear, distinct reflection of light, almost like a mirror. Low-quality lustre appears dull, hazy, or chalky. Lustre is the soul of the pearl and is the single greatest indicator of its beauty and value.

What to look for: Hold the pearl under a light source. Can you see a sharp, clear reflection on its surface? The sharper the reflection, the higher the lustre.

2. Surface Quality

This refers to the number and visibility of blemishes on the pearl's surface. These can include spots, bumps, wrinkles, or cracks. Since pearls are organic products, it is natural for them to have some imperfections. The value is determined by how clean the surface appears to the naked eye.

What to look for: Examine the pearl. Are blemishes obvious and numerous, or are they minor and difficult to see? A pearl with a clean surface is rarer and more valuable.

3. Shape

Pearls come in three broad shape categories:

Round: The rarest and most valued shape, especially for strand necklaces.
Near-Round: Appears round to the eye but is not perfectly spherical. It offers excellent value.
Baroque: Any irregular, non-spherical shape. This includes button (flattened), oval, drop, and completely abstract shapes. Baroque pearls are unique and often used in designer jewellery.

For classic strands and stud earrings, round is traditionally preferred. For fashion pieces, baroque shapes offer a unique character and are more affordable.

4. Colour

A pearl's colour has three components:

Bodycolour: The pearl's dominant overall colour (e.g., white, cream, silver, gold, black).
Overtone: A translucent colour that seems to lie over the body colour. For example, a white pearl might have a rose or green overtone.
Orient: A rare, iridescent rainbow-like play of colour on or just below the surface. It is most often seen in high-quality Tahitian pearls.

Personal preference plays a large role in colour choice. However, in the case of South Sea and Tahitian pearls, certain natural colours (like golden and peacock) are rarer and command higher prices.

5. Size

Size is measured in millimetres. Larger pearls are rarer and take longer to grow, so all other factors being equal, a larger pearl will be more valuable than a smaller one. However, a small pearl with exceptional lustre will always be more valuable than a large, dull pearl.

Understanding Pearl Grading Systems

There is no universal, industry-standard grading system for pearls. Different companies use different scales. The most common system you will encounter uses letters.

The AAA-A System: This is a common system, but its application can vary.

- AAA: The highest grade. Pearls are nearly flawless, with a high, sharp lustre. They are at least 95% blemish-free on the surface. The shape is perfectly round.
- AA: High to medium lustre. The surface will have some visible imperfections, but they are not major. The shape is round or near-round. This grade offers excellent value.
- A: The lowest grade typically used for jewellery. These pearls have lower lustre and more obvious surface blemishes. They may be off-round or baroque in shape.

Important Note: A grade from one vendor is not necessarily equivalent to the same grade from another. Always use the grade as a general guide and trust your own eyes. A pearl's beauty is best judged in person.

A Practical Guide to Buying Pearls

Buying In-Store:

Examine the Lustre First: This is your priority. Compare different strands under the store lights.
Check the Surface: Look closely for any major blemishes that detract from the beauty.
Feel the Weight: High-quality pearls with thick nacre have a slight heft to them.
Check the Drilling: The holes should be clean and neat, not chipped or rough.
Examine the Setting: For pearl earrings or rings, ensure the setting is secure and the metal is of good quality (e.g., 14k gold instead of gold-plated).

Buying Online:

Buy from Reputable Retailers: Choose established jewellers who specialise in pearls. Read their "About Us" and educational pages.
Scrutinise the Photos and Videos: Look for high-resolution images on a white or neutral background. A good retailer will provide a video that shows the lustre and colour play.
Understand the Return Policy: Always ensure there is a no-questions-asked return period (e.g., 30 days). This allows you to see the pearls in person.
Read the Description Carefully: It should specify the pearl type, size, and grade. Be wary of vague terms like "luxury grade."

How to Care for Your Pearls

Pearls are soft (2.5-3.5 on the Mohs scale) and organic, so they require gentle care.

Last On, First Off: Put your pearls on after applying perfume, hairspray, and cosmetics. Take them off first when you get home.
Wipe Them Down: After wearing, gently wipe them with a soft, damp cloth to remove body oils and sweat.
Store Them Separately: Keep pearls in a soft pouch or a separate compartment in your jewellery box. Do not let them rub against harder gems or metals.
Re-string Regularly: If you wear a pearl strand often, have it re-strung by a professional every year or two. The silk thread can stretch and weaken over time.

Your Pearl Jewellery Questions Answered

Are cultured pearls "real" pearls? Yes. They are formed inside a live mollusc through the exact same natural process as a natural pearl. The only difference is that the initial stimulus was provided by a human.

Why are some pearls so inexpensive? Inexpensive pearls are typically lower-grade Freshwater pearls. They may have lower lustre, more blemishes, and irregular shapes. They are a great entry point into pearl ownership.

What is the best type of pearl for everyday wear? A strand of Akoya pearls or a simple pair of Freshwater pearl studs is classic and durable enough for regular wear.

Can pearls get wet? They can occasionally get wet, but you should avoid submerging them in water (e.g., swimming, showering). Water can weaken the silk thread of a necklace and, over time, harm the nacre.

Do pearls last forever? With proper care, high-quality pearls can last for generations and become family heirlooms. Their surface can wear over many decades, but their beauty endures.

Find Your Perfect Pearl

Choosing a pearl is a personal journey. It is about finding a gem that reflects light—and your style—in a way that feels right to you. Whether it is the classic brilliance of an Akoya, the soft glow of a Freshwater pearl, the exotic drama of a Tahitian, or the luxurious glow of a South Sea pearl, there is a pearl for every taste and occasion.

Arm yourself with the knowledge of lustre, surface, and shape. Let your eye be the final judge of beauty. Your perfect pearl is out there, waiting to be discovered and cherished.